top of page
  • Jay Brothers

Bethel Place/ Pillow-Bethel House: The Third Pillow Mansion

Jerome Bonaparte Pillow (1809-1891) and Elvira Dale Pillow (1816-1889) built Pillow-Bethell House/ Bethell Place in 1855 on 1,200 acres.

Photo from Experience Maury Co TN

It is located on Mt. Pleasant Pike and is in 2 story brick Greek Revival style. Pillow-Bethell House was the third large home built by the Pillow brothers. The grandfather, John Pillow, came to the Cumberland settlement in 1784. His son, Gideon, journeyed south to the emerging Maury Co. area as a surveyor. He purchased 5,000 acres and settled in 1808. Gideon built a mill nearby on Little Bigsby Creek.

When he died in 1830, the property was split between the three sons. Jerome was the third brother in a family of prosperous Maury Co. planters. After Jerome’s death, their daughter, Cynthia Saunders Pillow Bethell (1841-1924), inherited the home and resided there with her husband William Decatur Bethell (1840-1906). He established the Bethell House Hotel in downtown Columbia which operated until 1949 when it burned.

The home has remained in the family. In 1943, Charles Worthington Jewell (1912-1990) and Sarah Ann Jewell (1915-1993) purchased the property which still had 750 acres and restored it by 1959. His family operates a working farm called Jewell Farm Smoked Hams and sell to customers. They also owned Rattle and Snap for a short time. In 2018, daughter Eva James Jewell Crichton and her husband Andrew run it. NRHP 1976 See also Clifton Place, Rattle and Snap, Rose Hill

Recent Posts

See All

Halcyon Hall

212 West 6th St. Columbia, TN Circa 1845. Built in 1845, Joseph Alfred Walker (1810-1882) and Adaline Ann Elizabeth Nelson Walker (1818-1868) lived in Halcyon Hall. They wed in 1832. The property stoo


bottom of page